Home Schooling Educational Neglect

/by

Child neglect can take many forms. The failure to provide for a child’s basic survival needs, such as food, shelter, clothing, medical care, and hygiene, constitutes physical neglect. This type of neglect may also involve a disregard for a child’s safety, such as not providing adequate supervision.

Educational neglect involves a parent’s failure to enroll a school-age child in appropriate classes or provide them with appropriate homeschooling. In many states, like Connecticut, educational neglect can be a vague concept that can bring the Department of Children and Families (DCF) knocking on your door to investigate.

What is Educational Neglect in Connecticut?

The Department of Children and Families in Connecticut broadly defines educational neglect as excessive absences from school. If the DCF discovers that you caused your child to miss too much time from school, they may be able to substantiate a finding of Educational Neglect against you.

But Connecticut’s compulsory education statute doesn’t require that you send your child to a specific public or private school. You can be exempt from this law as long as you can show that the child is receiving instruction equivalent to what is taught in public schools.

Some states require that homeschooling parents notify a particular state agency of their intentions to homeschool their children. Connecticut doesn’t have this requirement, but the Department of Education does “suggest” parents fill out an Intent to Homeschool form annually. Any rules for reporting are implemented at the school district level, not the state level.

Reporting Educational Neglect in Connecticut

When there is suspicion that a child is being denied proper care and attention educationally, a concerned individual can report the failure to educate in a homeschool setting to the Connecticut DCF.

Once the DCF receives one of these reports, it will initiate an investigation. As a parent, you probably won’t know that anyone has questions about your homeschooling activities until you get a knock on your door from a DCF investigator. This can be a frightening prospect.

The DCF has a lot of power, so it’s important to remain calm and use caution if you are contacted. While you don’t want to appear uncooperative, you are also not required to let a DCF investigator into your home or answer questions without first consulting with an attorney. You can politely tell the investigator that you wish to protect your rights and will have your attorney get in touch immediately.

Why Homeschooling Educational Neglect Cases Can Be a Problem

According to a recent report in the CT Mirror, more than 17,800 fewer students showed up for school in 2021 than the prior year. When the pandemic shut down in-person learning in 2020, many families opted not to have students return to the classroom when given the option. But a lot of those students also weren’t logging on from home for virtual learning sessions, either.

The drop in school attendance was found to be disproportionately high in some of the state’s lowest-income districts. At the same time, the number of families reported to the DCF for educational neglect last year doubled compared to previous years. A combination of economic and healthcare crises has led many families throughout the state to become displaced. And the last thing parents and their minor children need is to find out they’re under investigation by DCF.

According to the same report, when DCF staff and social workers investigated this massive number of new reports, it turned out that the actual cases of educational neglect were somewhat small.

Housing insecurity and instability are major factors that contribute to school absenteeism and the need for homeschooling. According to state data, homeless children had the highest rates of absenteeism last year, with most of the students located in underserved districts. But that doesn’t necessarily mean DCF needs to be involved.

Education professionals, medical staff, and neighbors might contact the DCF to report educational neglect when parents are simply trying to provide for their child’s basic needs or dealing with other serious issues.

Contact an Experienced Connecticut DCF Defense Attorney Today

Whether you have decided to homeschool your child, or they are enrolled in some other program, you don’t want the DCF involved in your child’s education or your family life. If you find out that you are under investigation for educational neglect, you need the assistance of a qualified defense attorney.

The Christie Law Firm, LLC in Hartford, is dedicated to helping parents and their children who are forced to deal with DCF. Attorney Christie has years of experience handling these cases and will fiercely advocate for your interests inside and outside the courtroom. Please call (860) 461-7494 or contact us online to schedule a free initial consultation.

 

What Can I Do if a Doctor Who Suspects Child Abuse Contacts Connecticut DCF?

/by

Doctors, teachers, school employees, and certain other professionals who work with children are child abuse mandatory reporters in Connecticut. This means that if they suspect that a child is being abused or neglected, they have an ethical and professional obligation to report the suspicions of abuse, as well as any evidence of abuse that they have seen or collected, to the Connecticut Department of Children and Families (DCF). If a doctor makes a report of suspected abuse, it’s important that you understand your rights as a parent or guardian. Here is an overview of what you can do if a doctor who suspects child abuse contacts Connecticut DCF.

What Happens After an Allegation of Abuse or Neglect Is Made?

After the DCF receives a report of alleged abuse or neglect, a social worker will be assigned to the case and they will contact the child’s parent/guardian(s). The DCF takes a very hands-on approach in investigating allegations of abuse.

If the allegation implies that the child is at imminent risk of harm, DCF is required to make its best efforts to initiate the investigation within two hours of receiving the notice; otherwise, DCF should make its best efforts to initiate the investigation within 72 hours of receiving a notice of alleged abuse.

A DCF investigation usually involves touring the child’s home, talking with all family members, and potentially speaking to others in the community. In most cases, the DCF will also conduct a child interview. The DCF investigator is required to minimize the number of times that they interview a child.

At the conclusion of the case, DCF will either refer the family to a community provider for voluntary service if there is a finding of no significant risk for harm, or, if there is a finding of significant risk for harm, the DCF will move forward with a petition alleging that the child is being abused or neglect. 

What to Do Following a Report of Abuse to the DCF

While most DCF investigations result in a referral to a local provider and a finding of no significant risk for harm, DCF investigations are not something to be taken lightly. If there has been an allegation made against you and the DCF is opening an investigation, you should take action immediately to protect your rights and your relationship with your child. Things to do include:

  • Contact an attorney. Working with a skilled Connecticut DCF investigations lawyer is strongly recommended, even if the DCF hasn’t yet made a finding of risk for harm. Your attorney can guide you through your legal rights and help you to understand your options.
  • Tell the social worker you want to speak with an attorney first. DCF may show up at your house unannounced before you’ve had an opportunity to consult with an attorney. If this happens, you can tell the social worker that you want to talk with an attorney first.
  • Ask about the details of the allegations. DCF will protect the confidentiality of the person who made the report; however, you do deserve to know why DCF is investigating you. The more information you have, the better you’ll be able to defend yourself if necessary.
  • Start thinking about evidence. It’s important to start preparing evidence that you might have that refutes allegations of abuse. For example, you may want to think about family and friends who can serve as witnesses if your case moves into a hearing, or video footage that explains a child’s injuries, or other documentary evidence that can support your case.
  • It’s important that you cooperate with DCF and remain polite and professional throughout all interactions, regardless of how frustrating the investigation may be. DCF will do whatever it needs to do to draft its report and issue its findings—if you hinder this process, it will only reflect poorly on you and may delay the process. If you have questions about what cooperation looks like, connect with your attorney.

Call Our DCF Investigations Attorney Directly Today

If you have been accused of child abuse or neglect and a mandatory reporter has filed a complaint with the DCF against you, DCF will launch an investigation into the allegations. When this happens, it’s important to seek legal counsel, stay calm, and review your rights and the process. At the office of The Christie Law Firm, our DCF investigations attorney provides representation and defense during DCF cases. To learn more about what to do if a doctor reports you to the DCF, please contact our lawyer directly online, in person, or by phone at 860-461-7494.

What is the Definition of Child Abuse and Child Neglect in Connecticut?

/by

Connecticut child abuse laws aim to protect children from serious harm. They are often successful. But, unfortunately, many allegations of abuse and neglect are exaggerated or unfounded. Given the sensitive nature of these cases, child abuse and neglect are treated as serious crimes, and a conviction can lead to severe penalties.

Allegations of child abuse can create havoc for parents. A conviction means long-lasting consequences, including jail time, fines, and the potential loss of parental rights. If you are facing an investigation by the Connecticut Department of Children and Families (DCF) or have charges of child abuse or neglect against you, you need to speak with an experienced Connecticut child abuse defense attorney immediately.

Definition of Child Abuse and Neglect in Connecticut

Child Abuse

In Connecticut, the term “abuse” means that a child has been physically injured through other than accidental means or is in a condition resulting from maltreatment that includes cruel punishment, emotional maltreatment, sexual abuse, or deprivation of necessities.

The state differentiates between physical, sexual, and emotional abuse.

  • Physical Abuse involves injuries inconsistent with the history provided about them. Evidence includes injuries, malnutrition, and death.
  • Sexual Abuse is any incident involving a child’s non-accidental exposure to sexual behavior. Evidence includes incest, sexual exploitation, grooming, and disease.
  • Emotional Abuse involves any statements, threats, or acts which adversely impact a child and/or interferes with their positive emotional development. Evidence includes degrading, intimidating, or rejecting a child, and indicators include anxiety, depression, academic regression, and suicidal ideation.

Child Neglect

In Connecticut, a child can be found “neglected” who, for reasons other than being impoverished:

  • Has been abandoned
  • Has been abused
  • Has been denied property physical, emotional, educational, or moral care and attention
  • Is allowed to live under injurious circumstances or conditions

The state differentiates between physical, emotional, medical, and educational neglect.

  • Physical Neglect involves abuse, abandonment, or being deprived of the basics for survival. Evidence of physical neglect includes malnutrition, inadequate clothing, inadequate shelter, or inadequate supervision.
  • Emotional Neglect involves refusing to give a child the appropriate support, care, and attention. Evidence includes low self-esteem, emotional instability, and sleep issues.
  • Medical Neglect involves the refusal of or unreasonable delay or medical, dental, or mental health services. Evidence includes missed appointments or withholding necessary care from a sick child.
  • Educational Neglect involves the action or inaction related to the education of a child between the ages of 5 and 18. Evidence includes failing to register a child for school or ensure regular school attendance.

DCF’s Role in Connecticut Child Abuse and Neglect Cases

When there is an allegation of child abuse or neglect, DCF becomes involved by opening an investigation. The agency might attempt to remove the child/children from the home if they believe they are in danger.

DCF investigations can be intrusive, stressful, and lengthy. The agency will schedule home visits and may ask you to sign agreements that give them the right to extend their authority over you and your relationship with your children.

Many families find it helpful to work with an attorney who can advise them on how to deal with DCF and even act as a liaison with investigators.

Criminal Charges for Child Abuse and Neglect

When someone alleges child abuse or neglect, the police often become involved as well as DCF. The police can investigate the situation and file criminal charges if they believe the situation warrants it.

In Connecticut, it’s not uncommon for authorities to file charges for Risk of Injury to a Minor, which is a felony and covers a broad range of conduct. If you are convicted of this charge, you could face jail time, fines, and lose your parental rights.

Defenses for Child Abuse and Neglect Claims

Given that these are sensitive offenses, crimes against children are harshly prosecuted in Connecticut. Even so, many of these allegations are the result of ill intentions on the part of one parent against another or a misunderstanding.

Several defenses can result in reduced charges or a case dismissal. Some of the defenses that our law firm has had experience using include:

  • False accusations
  • Accidental harm
  • Insufficient evidence of neglect or abuse
  • Parental right to discipline a child

Every case is unique, so the best strategy will depend on your particular circumstances.

Contact an Experienced Connecticut DCF Defense Attorney

If you are a parent in Connecticut and have been accused of abuse or neglect, your parental rights may be at stake. You may also be facing some severe consequences if you are convicted of a crime. These situations rarely work themselves out. It’s vital that you take immediate steps to protect your rights and freedom.

At The Christie Law Firm LLC, Attorney Nicole Christie has years of experience working DCF cases and extensive knowledge of this state’s applicable laws. Call our Hartford office today at (860) 461-7494 to schedule an initial consultation.

What is Child Abandonment in Connecticut?

/by

As a parent, your relationship with your child or children is one of the most precious things you have. But it only takes a single poor decision or a miscommunication for you to jeopardize your rights as a parent.

The Connecticut Department of Children and Families (DCF) has a lot of power when it comes to taking steps to sever those rights. DCF only needs to file a “Termination of Parental Rights” (TPR) petition before the court, demonstrating why a parent’s rights should end. Then, you are instantly put on the defensive and must defend your interests. And, once your parental rights are terminated, they cannot be reinstated.

One of the most common grounds for terminating parental rights is abandonment. Accusations of abandonment can take a variety of forms. As a parent, it is vital that you understand your rights and Connecticut law pertaining to abandonment.

What is Child Abandonment in Connecticut?

In Connecticut, child abandonment is an illegal act. Not only can a parent be prosecuted for endangering a child, but they also risk the permanent termination of their parental rights by the courts.

Connecticut law defines abandonment as “a parent’s failure to maintain a reasonable degree of interest, concern, or responsibility as to the welfare of the child.” Further, a child has been abandoned if they are “left without provision for reasonable and necessary care or supervision.” Sporadic and occasional attempts to have contact with or provide support to a child are not considered sufficient or reasonable by the courts.

Whether intentional or not, child abandonment can occur in a variety of situations. Some examples of these include:

  • Abandoning an infant on a person’s doorstep, in a trash can, or on the side of the road;
  • Leaving a child with someone else for three months or longer without communicating with the child or making arrangements for the child’s support;
  • Refusing to provide a child with the necessary support, care, and supervision they need;
  • Leaving a child alone for a period that increases the risk of harm to them or others;
  • Making minimal attempts to communicate and form a relationship with the child; or
  • Not responding to notices of local and state child protective hearings.

In Connecticut, there are legal ways that children, including newborns, can be safely relinquished to the state. But these also involve voluntary termination of parental rights.

Things to Consider Before Moving Out of Your Home

Divorce and other domestic matters can be incredibly stressful and emotional. Continuing to live in your home during a turbulent period may not seem like the best idea, but it is important to understand the potential consequences of leaving.

If you have minor children, the last thing you want is to be accused of abandoning them. In some cases, it’s better to have a written temporary custody, visitation, and support agreement in place before you decide to move out and leave your children in the care of your ex.

What Happens If You’ve Been Accused of Child Abandonment?

If DCF believes you have abandoned your child, they can ask the courts to terminate your parental rights. Specifically, DCF would need to file a petition in the probate court, usually where the child resides. If the child is over the age of 12, they must be joined in the petition.

Aside from DCF, the following parties can petition the courts to terminate parental rights in Connecticut:

  • The other parent;
  • A child’s guardian;
  • A relative of a child who has been abandoned by their parent(s); or
  • A person caring for a foundling child.

After the petition to terminate parental rights has been filed with the probate court, there must be a hearing within 30 days. The court must appoint a guardian ad litem to represent the interests of the child, and parents that are facing a TPR petition also have the right to an attorney.

Before the hearing, there will be a DCF investigation as part of the process. The petition must prove their case, and the court must also find that termination is in the best interests of the child before making a final ruling.

Speak With An Experienced Connecticut DCF Defense Attorney

If you are a parent in Connecticut who has been accused of abandonment, your parental rights may be at stake. Don’t wait another minute hoping things will get better on their own. This isn’t likely to happen, and most parents find that the situation only gets worse.

If DCF is involved in your life, you need an experienced attorney on your side that will fiercely advocate for your interests. Attorney Nicole Christie at The Christie Law Firm LLC has extensive knowledge of Connecticut’s relevant statutes and experience working with DCF cases. Contact our Hartford office today at (860) 461-7494 to schedule a free consultation.

Where Does Disciplining Your Child Cross the Line to Neglect or Abuse?

/by

Drawing the line between a parent’s right to discipline their child and child abuse or neglect will depend on the specifics of the law. No parent likes to be told by the state how to discipline their own children. But if the Connecticut Department of Children and Families (DCF) is investigating an allegation of child neglect or abuse regarding excessive punishment or you already have a DCF Safety Plan in place, you have reason to be concerned.

How Does Connecticut Define Child Abuse or Neglect?

Connecticut law defines child abuse is broadly defined as when a parent or caretaker emotionally, physically, or sexually abuses, neglects, or abandons a child. According to DCT these situations typically involve a minor who has been:

  • Has been inflicted with physical injury or injuries other than by accidental means,
  • Is in a condition which is the result of maltreatment such as, but not limited to: malnutrition, sexual molestation, deprivation of necessities, emotional maltreatment or cruel punishment,
  • Has injuries at variance with the history given of them.

Evidence of physical abuse often includes:

  • Excessive physical punishment,
  • Bruises, scratches, lacerations,
  • Burns, and/or scalds,
  • Injuries to bone, muscle, cartilage, or ligaments,
  • Head injuries,
  • Internal injuries.

The state defines child neglect as a situation in which a parent or guardian fails to provide and maintain adequate food, supervision, clothing, education, and medical care, whether intentional or not. Neglect includes minors who are abused or abandoned.

Can You Get in Trouble in Connecticut for Disciplining Your Child?

Parents have the right to choose reasonable methods of disciplining their children. And most of the options that parents choose don’t cross the line to neglect or abuse. Parents who choose to use physical discipline must ensure that it does not injure their child. Parents should also avoid depriving their children of necessities like shelter and food as punishment.

The Connecticut Department of Children and Families (DCF) recommends that parents avoid using physical punishment to discipline their children. Parents who end up in front of a judge defending their rights are often instructed to avoid using any type of physical discipline. Parenting classes, which might be mandatory in some cases, emphasize alternative forms of discipline methods such as time-outs, restrictions on favorite activities, and increased chores.

Allegations of child abuse are not uncommon when parents are in the midst of a heated custody battle. True or not, one parent may believe that they can get an advantage during a custody dispute by claiming that the other’s methods of discipline qualify as abuse or neglect.

For these reasons, some attorneys will advise clients to avoid using physical discipline when there is an ongoing DCF investigation or custody battle.

Our Connecticut Appellate Court found that DCF must assess the reasonableness of the punishment in light of the child’s misbehavior and the surrounding circumstances, including the parent’s motive, the type of punishment administered, the amount of force used and the child’s age, size and ability to understand the punishment.

What is Crossing the Line With Child Discipline?

In most states, Connecticut included, the abuse and neglect prevention laws are created to protect the rights of children. Some parents who physically discipline their children do not intend to do harm but also aren’t aware when they cross the line into an area that qualifies as abuse.

Too much force can break bones, leave marks, or traumatize a child. If marks or trauma are the result of punishment, the state might take exception and charge a parent with abuse.

Again, crossing the line can happen quickly and without intention. A parent that pulls a child’s arm and dislocates their shoulder might get a visit from DCF. Likewise, a child that suffers lasting emotional or physical problems due to shame or humiliation or the withholding of essential items like food has likely experienced abuse or neglect in the eyes of the law.

What Happens If DCF Files a Neglect Petition?

Law enforcement or DCF can become involved in child discipline cases in a variety of ways. They might be contacted by a concerned healthcare provider, teacher, or neighbor. In some cases, the other parent or the child will contact law enforcement. Not every case that is reported constitutes child abuse or neglect, but many reports are likely to trigger a neglect petition with DCF.

If DCF files a neglect petition, the first thing you should do is speak with an attorney who is experienced in these cases. DCF must prove its case, but the stakes are high. The agency has the right to recommend either Protective Supervision or ask that the court remove the child from your home.

You will have the opportunity to respond to the petition and present evidence at a hearing. But it is to your benefit to have an attorney in your corner that can represent your interests and safeguard your parental rights.

Speak With A Connecticut DCF Defense Lawyer

Disciplining your child can be a controversial subject. Everyone has a right to their opinion on this, but parents are encouraged to use caution in their choices. It is within your legal rights as a parent to spank or discipline your child in Connecticut but be aware of the state’s law.

Police and DCF investigations are incredibly invasive and can also be traumatic for a family.

For this reason, it is essential to have an experienced attorney who can protect your rights. At The Christie Law Firm, our attorney focuses on defending parents against child abuse and neglect allegations, and we invite you to contact us at (860) 461-7494 or reach out to us online to schedule an initial consultation.